Affiliate Disclosure: PickClarity earns commissions from qualifying purchases through our partner links. Our rankings are editorially independent — they are never influenced by affiliate relationships or commission rates. Learn more about our methodology.

#2 in Gym Floor MatsRunner-Up

Horse Stall Mat

Name: Horse Stall Mat
Brand: Tractor Supply
Rating: 9.2 (1 reviews)

Tractor Supply

$49.00 – $59.00

4x6 foot heavy-duty rubber mat measuring 3/4 inch thick originally designed for equine use. Weighs approximately 100 lbs and provides excellent impact absorption for dropped weights. The most popular and cost-effective flooring solution in the home gym community.

9.2

Excellent

Consensus

Our Analysis

Ranked #2 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.

Score Breakdown

Expert Score

9.1

User Sentiment

9.3

Value Score

9.0

Complaint Risk

9.1

Freshness

8.5

Community

8.3

Availability

8.8

Pros

Best value per square foot available
Best value per square foot available
Extremely durable for any gym use
Extremely durable for any gym use
3/4 inch thickness handles heavy drops
3/4 inch thickness handles heavy drops

Cons

Very strong rubber smell for weeks
Very strong rubber smell for weeks
Heavy and requires in-store pickup
Heavy and requires in-store pickup

Don't buy this if…

These mats must typically be picked up in-store as shipping costs exceed the mat price.
These mats must typically be picked up in-store as shipping costs exceed the mat price.