Affiliate Disclosure: PickClarity earns commissions from qualifying purchases through our partner links. Our rankings are editorially independent — they are never influenced by affiliate relationships or commission rates. Learn more about our methodology.

#7 in ATV Tires

Carlisle AT489

Name: Carlisle AT489
Brand: Carlisle
Rating: 8.1 (1 reviews)

Carlisle

$60.00 – $120.00

OEM-fitment utility tire with a square shoulder profile, staggered tread blocks, and 4 to 6-ply options for farm and trail duty. The go-to cheap replacement that fits hundreds of stock utility ATVs.

8.1

Good

Consensus

Our Analysis

Ranked #7 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.

Score Breakdown

Expert Score

8.1

User Sentiment

8.2

Value Score

9.0

Complaint Risk

8.7

Freshness

8.6

Community

9.0

Availability

8.5

Pros

Cheapest reputable replacement tire
Matches many OEM fitments exactly
Predictable, stable utility handling

Cons

Unimpressive in mud or rocks
Softer casing punctures easier than 8-ply

Don't buy this if…

Don't buy for aggressive recreational riding, since this is a workhorse tire, not a performance one.

Discussion (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to share your experience!

Where to Buy

Affiliate links · Prices may vary

Carlisle AT489

Our Analysis

Score Breakdown

Pros

Cons

Don't buy this if…

Discussion (0)

Where to Buy

More in ATV Tires

SunF A027

GBC Grim Reaper

Kenda Bearclaw K299

Sedona Rip-Saw R/T