Garmin Index S2 vs Withings Body Smart
Compare features and trade-offs. Catalog scores are editorial assessments, not customer review averages or proof of hands-on testing.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Catalog price ranges are estimates; check the exact model, seller, and current retailer price.
Facts and prices checked
Withings Body Smart for most people, Index S2 for Garmin users
We rank the Withings Body Smart ahead of the Garmin Index S2. Both sync over Wi-Fi and show results on a color display. The Body Smart costs $70 less at list price, runs longer on its batteries, adds standing heart rate and BMR to its metrics, and offers Pregnancy and Baby, Athlete, and Eyes Closed modes. The Index S2 is still the better fit if you already track workouts in Garmin Connect, since its readings land alongside your watch data, and it supports up to 16 users. If you do not use Garmin devices, the Body Smart is the better value.
Key differences
| Garmin Index S2 | Withings Body Smart | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $199.99 on Garmin's US store | $129.95 on Withings' US store |
| App ecosystem | Syncs to Garmin Connect alongside Garmin watch data | Syncs to the Withings app; optional Withings+ at $9.95 a month or $99.50 a year |
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi sync; Garmin lists BLE and ANT compatibility | Wi-Fi or Bluetooth; Withings says readings sync without your phone nearby |
| Users | Up to 16 user profiles | Recognizes up to 8 users |
| Metrics | Weight, BMI, body fat, skeletal muscle mass, bone mass, and body water (body composition is manufacturer-estimated) | Weight, fat, muscle, water, standing heart rate, and BMR (body composition is manufacturer-estimated) |
| Battery | Up to 9 months on 4 AAA batteries | Over 15 months on replaceable batteries |
| Display and modes | Color display that reviewers say can show a weight trend graph and the weather; layout is customizable in the app | High-resolution color display with Athlete, Pregnancy and Baby, and Eyes Closed modes |
Which one for your seat and trip
Garmin watch owner
Pick: Garmin Index S2
Readings go straight into Garmin Connect with your activity data.
Apple, Fitbit, or no wearable
Pick: Withings Body Smart
You avoid paying extra for Garmin ecosystem features, and it costs $70 less at list price.
Large household
Pick: Garmin Index S2
It supports up to 16 profiles versus 8 on the Body Smart.
Weighing a baby or tracking during pregnancy
Pick: Withings Body Smart
It has a dedicated Pregnancy and Baby mode.
Choose Garmin Index S2 if…
- you already use a Garmin watch and want weight data in Garmin Connect next to your training.
- more than 8 people in your home will use one scale, since it supports up to 16 profiles.
- you like a customizable display that can show a weight trend graph at weigh-in.
Choose Withings Body Smart if…
- you want a Wi-Fi scale for less money, at $129.95 versus $199.99.
- you want to change batteries less often, with Withings rating it at over 15 months.
- you want household modes like Pregnancy and Baby or Eyes Closed, which hides the number at weigh-in.