Best Ice Cream Makers
Top ice cream makers ranked by transparent trust scores.
8 products ranked
Affiliate Disclosure: PickClarity earns commissions from qualifying purchases through our partner links. Our rankings are editorially independent — they are never influenced by affiliate relationships or commission rates. Learn more about our methodology.
Find the best for your needs:
Top Pick
9.4
Excellent
Cuisinart ICE-21P1 Frozen Yogurt & Ice Cream Maker
Ranked #1 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
#1
9.4
Excellent
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #1 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Simple and affordable
- 1.5-quart family-size batches
- Churns in 20 minutes
Cons
- Bowl requires 12-24 hour pre-freeze
- Only one batch per freeze cycle
Don't buy this if…
- The freezer bowl must be frozen for a full 24 hours before use; a partially frozen bowl produces soupy, under-churned results.
#2
9.2
Excellent
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #2 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- No pre-freezing required
- Automatic hardness settings
- Keep-cool holds temperature 3 hours
Cons
- Heavy at 30 pounds
- Expensive investment
Don't buy this if…
- The compressor generates heat during operation; leave at least 4 inches of clearance around the unit for ventilation.
#3
9.0
Excellent
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #3 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Seven one-touch programs
- Makes ice cream, sorbet, and smoothie bowls
- Pint-size portions reduce waste
Cons
- Must freeze base 24 hours in advance
- Pint-size batches are small for families
Don't buy this if…
- Each pint container must freeze for a full 24 hours; the unit cannot process liquid bases or partially frozen containers.
#4
8.7
Excellent
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #4 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- No pre-freezing needed
- Large 2.1-quart capacity
- Stainless steel mixing bowl
Cons
- Heavy and bulky for storage
- Motor can be noisy during churning
Don't buy this if…
- The compressor needs 10 minutes of rest between consecutive batches to reset; running back-to-back batches without pausing reduces quality.
#5
8.5
Excellent
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #5 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Uses existing KitchenAid mixer
- 2-quart capacity
- No separate motor to store
Cons
- Requires a KitchenAid stand mixer
- Bowl needs 15-hour pre-freeze
Don't buy this if…
- This attachment only works with KitchenAid stand mixers; it is not a standalone ice cream maker and has no motor of its own.
#6
8.3
Good
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #6 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Large 4-quart party-size batches
- Authentic ice-and-salt method
- Affordable price
Cons
- Requires bags of ice and rock salt
- Messy cleanup with salt water
Don't buy this if…
- You need approximately 10 pounds of ice and 2 cups of rock salt per batch; buy these supplies before your first use.
#7
8.1
Good
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #7 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Ultra-compact personal size
- Very affordable
- Perfect for single servings
Cons
- Tiny 1.6-cup capacity
- Bowl requires pre-freezing
Don't buy this if…
- The 1.6-cup capacity makes roughly one generous scoop; this is a single-serving maker, not suitable for families.
#8
7.9
Good
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #8 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Professional Italian-made quality
- Powerful commercial-grade compressor
- Gelato-shop results
Cons
- Very expensive
- Heavy at 38 pounds
Don't buy this if…
- This is a professional-grade appliance that weighs 38 pounds; plan a permanent counter location rather than storing and moving it.
Quick Comparison
How We Rank
Composite trust score from expert reviews, user sentiment, complaint analysis, and value assessment.
Trust Score
Weighted composite of all factor scores
Expert Score
Aggregated expert review ratings
User Sentiment
Community votes and review analysis
Value Score
Price-to-performance ratio
Freshness
Recency of reviews and data
Change Log
Discussion (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your experience!
AI Shopping Assistant
Ask questions about products in this category. Answers are grounded in our evidence data.
Try asking:
Get Alerts
Stay updated when rankings change or prices drop in Ice Cream Makers.