Best Crib Mattresses
Top crib mattresses ranked by transparent trust scores.
8 products ranked
Affiliate Disclosure: PickClarity earns commissions from qualifying purchases through our partner links. Our rankings are editorially independent — they are never influenced by affiliate relationships or commission rates. Learn more about our methodology.
Find the best for your needs:
Top Pick
9.4
Excellent
Newton Baby Crib Mattress
Ranked #1 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
#1
9.4
Excellent
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #1 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- 100% breathable core for safety
- Entire mattress is washable
- Greenguard Gold certified
Cons
- Premium price point
- Lighter weight than traditional mattresses
Don't buy this if…
- The breathable design means the mattress is lighter and may shift more easily in some crib frames.
#2
9.2
Excellent
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #2 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- GOTS-certified organic materials
- Food-grade waterproof surface
- No harmful foams or chemicals
Cons
- Heavy at 20+ lbs
- Higher price for organic certification
Don't buy this if…
- The heavyweight design makes sheet changes more difficult for parents who need to lift the mattress frequently.
#3
9.0
Excellent
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #3 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Excellent value under $80
- CertiPUR-US certified foam
- Water-resistant removable cover
Cons
- Single firmness level only
- Cover is water-resistant, not waterproof
Don't buy this if…
- The water-resistant cover is not fully waterproof; a separate waterproof mattress protector is recommended.
#4
8.7
Excellent
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #4 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Dual firmness for infant and toddler
- Medical-grade waterproof surface
- Greenguard Gold certified
Cons
- Must remember to flip at correct age
- Mid-range price point
Don't buy this if…
- Using the wrong side for baby's age is a safety concern; the softer toddler side is not appropriate for infants.
#5
8.5
Excellent
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #5 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Soy-enhanced eco-friendly foam
- Staph-Gard waterproof cover
- Trusted Sealy brand name
Cons
- Single firmness only
- Pearl-embossed cover can feel stiff initially
Don't buy this if…
- The waterproof cover can make a crinkling noise that may disturb light-sleeping babies.
#6
8.3
Good
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #6 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- 150-coil innerspring for firm support
- Budget-friendly price
- Hypoallergenic fiber wrap
Cons
- Heavier than foam mattresses
- Vinyl cover feels less premium
Don't buy this if…
- The vinyl waterproof cover may contain phthalates; consider an organic mattress pad as a barrier layer.
#7
8.1
Good
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #7 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Ultra-lightweight at only 7 lbs
- Dual-stage firmness
- Greenguard Gold certified
Cons
- Lightweight can mean less stable feel
- Higher price category
Don't buy this if…
- The ultra-lightweight design feels different from traditional mattresses and some parents perceive it as less substantial.
#8
7.9
Good
Consensus
Compare
Ranked #8 based on expert reviews, user sentiment, and value analysis.
Pros
- Most affordable innerspring option
- Standard size fits most cribs
- Meets all federal safety standards
Cons
- Basic vinyl cover
- Fewer coils than premium innerspring models
Don't buy this if…
- Budget innerspring mattresses may develop uneven spots sooner than higher-coil-count alternatives.
Quick Comparison
How We Rank
Composite trust score from expert reviews, user sentiment, complaint analysis, and value assessment.
Trust Score
Weighted composite of all factor scores
Expert Score
Aggregated expert review ratings
User Sentiment
Community votes and review analysis
Value Score
Price-to-performance ratio
Freshness
Recency of reviews and data
Change Log
Discussion (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your experience!
AI Shopping Assistant
Ask questions about products in this category. Answers are grounded in our evidence data.
Try asking:
Get Alerts
Stay updated when rankings change or prices drop in Crib Mattresses.